Meewella | Critic

According to P

Tag: Jake Ryan

QuickView: Asteroid City (2023)

“I still don’t understand the play.”

Augie Steenbeck

Wes Anderson’s recent films have begun to feel like pastiches of his own work. Asteroid City trades his usual literary trappings for theatrical ones, a meta narrative providing monochrome sequences — narrated by Bryan Cranston — about a play that is represented by a full-colour film in traditional Anderson style. The increased artifice makes it more difficult to connect with these characters who are now characters being portrayed by actors who are played by actors (with nothing quite so pithy as Tropic Thunder’s “I’m a dude playing a dude disguised as another dude.”). Ironically the most nuanced performance within the play is probably Scarlett Johanson’s… as a famous actress. The location, a desert town known only for its crater, feels less like a populated location than the empty shell of a theatrical set. It is unclear whether the 60s-era sci-fi technology is a deliberate anachronism or simple suited to Anderson’s aesthetic preferences. Although he blurs the edges at times, Anderson’s approach is neither as convoluted nor as ambitious as, say, Charlie Kaufman’s Synecdoche, New York. That makes it easier to switch off and enjoy the contrivance for what it is, but there is little substance here.

6/10

QuickView: Eighth Grade (2018)

Eighth Grade poster

“But it’s like, being yourself is, like, not changing yourself to impress someone else.”

Kayla

Bo Burnham’s directorial debut focuses his attuned voice on an unremarkable young girl clumsily navigating the final week of eighth grade (Year 9 in the UK), but its success is capturing the disconnect between adults and the children with whom they seek to communicate. Elsie Fisher’s astounding portrayal of Kayla’s shy awkwardness is what endears us to the quiet, thoughtful character. Although Kayla is permanently attached to her phone, technology hasn’t really changed the underlying angst as these new teenagers deal with crafting an identity away from their parents and seeking out platonic and romantic relationships. The female perspective invites comparisons with The Edge of Seventeen, but the smaller scope of its narrow timeframe makes Eighth Grade a slice of life rather than a coming-of-age story. Burnham is less interested in nostalgia than capturing reality. The most lasting impression came from Kayla’s YouTube vlogs that pepper the film as a form of narration, in which she earnestly offers the advice that she sorely needs herself.

8/10

"A film is a petrified fountain of thought."

(CC) BY-NC 2003-2023 Priyan Meewella

Up ↑