Meewella | Critic

According to P

Tag: Benoît Delhomme

QuickView: A Most Wanted Man (2014)

“And all that damage we leave behind. All those lives. All those empty rooms. What were they even for? You have asked yourself that question? Why we do what we do?”

Günther Bachmann

Adapted from a John le Carré novel inspired by the abduction and rendition from Germany of the innocent Murat Kurnaz, this is an old-fashioned slow burn thriller that could be criticised for its meandering nature were its explosive conclusion not so purposive and memorable. A Most Wanted Man is obliquely critical of American foreign policy and overreach, whilst exploring the moral conflicts on a personal level for both those in the intelligence services and those who cooperate with them. One of Philip Seymour Hoffman’s final films, released shortly after his death, he delivers a powerful central performance as an agent doggedly pursuing a terrorist financier whilst trying to protect his investigation from intervention by the local police or the USA. The focal point is a Chechnian fugutive who might be a refugee or a terrorist, an angle that remains relevant a decade later as refugees continue to be treated with suspicion. Rachel McAdams provides the counterpoint as a lawyer aiding the dispossessed, with Willem Dafoe the neutral banker caught unwillingly in the middle, though the film’s coldly clinical perspective limits our connection with any of the characters. A Most Wanted Man lacks the flair and intrigue of Tomas Alfredson’s Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy — for me the quintessential Le Carré adaptation — but it asks more pressing political questions.

7/10

QuickView: Lady Chatterley’s Lover (2022)

“I’ve thought a lot about what you said at the wedding — that I open my heart too easily. That may have been true before the war but I don’t think it is any longer.”

Connie

D.H. Lawrence’s once-outrageous novel has been the subject of numerous turgid adaptations that are typically derailed by their focus on titillation or scandalous romance, both aspects seeming tame by modern standards. The latest version, from director Laure de Clermont-Tonnerre, takes a broader approach to the material, which some see as Lawrence exploring what it takes to make a person feel whole, in contrast to the prevailing view that the upper class required only intellectual gratification whilst the lower class were subject to baser desires. We see parallels in Connie and the gameskeeper Oliver, both of whom read to fill the void left by unfulfilling marriages, and a book marks the fracturing of their relationship. There is a clear power disparity when the literate commoner catches her eye as Oliver lives on her estate (“they’re yours,” he points out when she initially declines to take flowers from his garden), and those looking for a deep romance may find themselves disappointed. Lady Chatterley’s Lover does not shy away from nudity, but in its most intimate scenes the camera’s focus is on faces and reactions, during and afterward. Emma Corrin, who rose to prominence for her portrayal of Princess Diana in The Crown, calls to mind Keira Knightley’s period roles in a layered performance as a woman struggling with loneliness and desire whilst her privilege makes her careless though not unkind. The morality of infidelity is avoided entirely since Clifford Chatterley is content to procure an heir through Connie having an affair, and his attitude towards the less privileged is contemptible. Instead, the film’s concern — the conundrum which faces Connie and worries her family — is what course of action will allow her to feel complete and fulfilled.

7/10

"A film is a petrified fountain of thought."

(CC) BY-NC 2003-2023 Priyan Meewella

Up ↑