Meewella | Critic

According to P

Tag: Alia Bhatt

QuickView: Heart of Stone (2023)

“Chance of success just plummeted.”

Jack of Hearts

Heart of Stone opens strongly with a mountainous MI6 mission that subverts the trope of field agents versus the techies stuck in the van; then the script intervenes and it at all begins to unravel into Netflix’s trademark action movie recipe of big name stars and poor writing. The plot centres around worldwide agency “The Charter” which, beholden to no government, is able to tackle problems that national security services cannot. Everyone receives an alias based on a deck of cards which probably sounded cool on paper but is used inconsistently and seems a highly impractical limitation for a globe-spanning organisation. They operate using “The Heart”, an algorithmic predictive engine that guides their actions — the script plays on fears about ceding decision-making control to AI, yet it seems that following the AI’s direction would have saved a lot of lives. This makes Stone’s rebelliousness harder for the audience to cheer, an essential component of these movies. The action itself includes a pleasing range of practical effects, much of the CGI budget being used to create The Heart’s interactive digital projections as events are analysed in real time back at base. That blend of technology gives Heart of Stone a visual identity of its own, even if there are few memorable set pieces. The result is another competent but forgettable action flick in Netflix’s search for a franchise.

5/10

Disclosure: I know personally at least one person involved in the making of this film

QuickView: RRR (2022)

“He said that an Indian’s life is not worth a bullet.”

Venkata Rama Raju

At a time when Britain is being asked (and largely refusing) to contend with its imperialist past, it is fascinating to observe how its former colonies are engaging in the same reflection on their occupied history. RRR’s dual protagonists might be real figures, but this is pure revolutionary fantasy filled with astounding action and cinematic crowd-pleasers in the most expensive Indian film to date. The story posits a fictional friendship between Raju and Bheem, destined to come into conflict, their buddy movie antics providing the emotional stakes that will follow. With the exception of love interest Jenny, the British are all depicted as cartoonishly villainous, but questions are also raised about the complicity of those who worked with the regime or whether they too were victims of oppression. The clear enemy provides for rousing scenes in the hands of director S.S. Rajamouli, from an exhilerating dance-off at a party to an assault with wild animals tearing through a British compound. The action choreography is gloriously silly — it is the sort of movie where one can punch a tiger in the face — and is guaranteed to leave you with a grin plastered across your face many times over. For all its cinematic success, it would be remiss not to highlight the risk of these patriotic pictures in a time of rising nationalism, particularly within a caste system that is reinforced by RRR’s elitist perspective in contrast to a film like Jai Bhim. Most troubling is a scene in which Bheem apologises for being a simple tribal who could not understand Raju’s wider goals ⁠— goals that were never communicated to him. That is a warning, but it does not detract from RRR’s triumph of creative excess that challenges Everything Everywhere All At Once.

9/10

"A film is a petrified fountain of thought."

(CC) BY-NC 2003-2025 Priyan Meewella

Up ↑